A thrilling duel in perfect conditions saw Mutiso almost catch Kipruto with a late burst in the final metres of what was the closest finish in New York Marathon history.
Kipruto crossed the line in a time of two hours eight minutes and nine seconds, with Mutiso 0.16secs behind.
Kenya's Albert Korir, the 2021 New York winner, was third in 2:08:57.
READ MORE
Kenyan enterprise behind solar powered healthcare among finalists in global sustainability prize
Wafcon slot in sight as Harambee Starlets face Gambia in crucial match
Gor Mahia hit form as Homeboyz, Posta lead tight Premier League race
Why it is not yet celebration moment for Harambee Starlets
Benyo, Chebet to lead Kenyan cast to Florida World Cross
Athletics stars upbeat as Eldoret gets ready for world cross trials
Harambee Starlets gear up for Gambia's Queen Scorpions